Title — Self and the City (back)
(References)
Rotterdam is where I currently live, and where I’m currently coming to understand my identity.
I arrived in Rotterdam when I was 19, from Scotland. I moved with a desire for adventure, initially pursuing an education in advertising, as well as communications and media. For me, Rotterdam is a city of “others”, of different, and in that difference is where I choose to express my sense of belonging.
However, the multiculturalism inherent in Rotterdam and the Netherlands at large continues to be a source of great contention both socially and politically. The city of Rotterdam attempts to broach the complexity of this subject through the cultural sphere, as seen in the newly constructed Fenix museum.
As The Guardian writes in conversation with the museum’s director, Anne Kremers, “Migration is timeless and universal... Migration is not always a story of suffering... [as] people also uproot themselves for love, for work, for adventure” (The Guardian, 2025, para. 3). Kremers described the development of the museum as “urgent” reflecting on the current political climate and rise of Anti-Foreigner sentiment in the Netherlands.
This article speaks to my experience, challenging the narratives of Migration. My move comes from a place of great privilege in comparison to the stories presented in the museum, however, my migration to Rotterdam acts as an essential component in constructing my identity within the city.
This idea of migration in relation to my own experience is an interesting one, specifically, when exploring the intersection of language and labelling and how identity, belonging, and integration can be discursively negotiated or discredited through language in multicultural contexts (Verkuyten, 2005).
While living in Rotterdam, I’ve witnessed a linguistic paradox. Wherein people label me a student first, and an expat or immigrant second. A kind of language assessment where I'm defined by what I communicate non-verbally and by what the observer constitutes as a display of my education, class, and race, as a factor in distinguishing what language to use. An experience which relates greatly to the concept of altercasting, where the imposition of language creates networks of meanings or connotations such that it becomes synonymous with an identity. “Identities are never autonomous or independent but always acquire social meaning in relation to other available identity positions and other social actors” (Bucholtz & Hall, 2005).
This phenomenon is often related to the other’s own perspectives of class, language, and politics, and as such is an example of selective perception. A person's beliefs and values reflect the way they evaluate my identity. Undoubtedly, I have the privilege of being a white British male, such that there is a certain kind of language reserved for me, which is much more forgiving than that used in relation to minority groups.
The term ‘immigrant’ is a legal category that refers to someone who voluntarily moves across nation-states for political, environmental, or economic reasons; the term ‘expat’ is not to be found in any official document. Rather, it is socially constructed depending on the local perception of the socioeconomic status of the migrant’s home country (Moretti et al., 2023).
My city-based identity is socially constructed through the nature of my migration, which may be perceived as having positive connotations rather than negative because of my country of origin and socio-economic background. This paradox is complex, and makes me think about the extent to which my city-based identity is discursive and subjective. Highlighting the extent to which language indexes my city-based identity, for instance, “expat” infers a certain social position, i.e., mobility, privilege, whiteness. (Bucholtz & Hall, 2005).
These experiences align with the concept of symbolic interactionism, concerning the implication of “broad social forces” in constructing an individual's view of self (Duck & McMahan, 2021). Therefore, my city-based identity is relational, my understanding of self is negotiated or discredited around the linguistic and discursive observations made by the “other”.
In conclusion, through this exercise, I've learned that my identity in the city of Rotterdam is a privileged one. I’ve learnt that identity is created, performed, and negotiated. I’ve learnt that irrespective of your personal view of self, your identity and its meanings are to some degree created by how others perceive you, which can be both positive and negative.